Increasing
crime in media and the importance of
laws to control it.
There is a
new report, commissioned by the Government, dealing with concerns about the
press. It was sparked by public revulsion about a single act – the hacking of
the mobile phone of a murdered teenager. From that beginning, it has expanded
to cover the culture, practices and ethics of the press and its conduct in
relation to the public, the police and politicians.
The media
is a very powerful industry. But this power and influence carries with it
responsibilities to the public interest in whose name it exercises these
privileges. Unfortunately, as the evidence has shown beyond doubt, on too many
occasions, those responsibilities (along with the Editors’ Code which the press
wrote and promoted) have simply been ignored. This has damaged the public interest,
caused real hardship and, also on occasion, wreaked havoc in the lives of
innocent people.
What
the press do and say is no ordinary exercise of free speech. It operates very
differently from blogs on the internet and other social media such as Twitter.
Its impact is uniquely powerful. A free press in a democracy holds power to
account. But, with a few honourable exceptions, the UK press has not performed
that vital role in the case of its own power.
None of
this, however, is to conclude that press freedom in Britain, hard won over 300
years ago, should be jeopardised. On the contrary, it should not. I remain
firmly of the belief that the British press – I repeat, all of it, – serves the
country very well for the vast majority of the time. There are truly countless
examples of great journalism, great investigations and great campaigns. Not
that it is necessary or appropriate for the press always to be pursuing serious
stories for it to be working in the public interest. Some of its most important
functions are to inform, educate and entertain and, when doing so, to be
irreverent, unruly and opinionated.
But none
of that means that the press is beyond challenge. I know of no organised
profession, industry or trade in which the serious failings of the few are
overlooked or ignored because of the good done by the many. Were it so in any
other case, the press would be the very first to expose such practices.
The
purpose of this Inquiry has been two fold. First, it has been to do just that –
to expose precisely what has been happening. Secondly, it is to make
recommendations for change. As to change, almost everyone accepts that the
Press Complaints Commission has failed in the task, if indeed it ever saw
itself as having such a task, of keeping the press to its responsibilities to
the public generally and to the individuals unfairly damaged.
There must
be change. But let me say this very clearly. Not a single witness proposed that
either Government or politicians all of whom the press hold to account, should
be involved in the regulation of the press.
Let
me deal very briefly with the idea that this Inquiry might not have been
necessary if the criminal law had simply operated more effectively. There were
errors in aspects of the way the phone hacking investigation was managed in
2006 and in relation to the failure to undertake later reviews, and there are
some problems that need to be fixed with the criminal and civil laws and also
in relation to data protection. In particular, exemplary damages should be
available for all media torts. In the end, however, law enforcement can never
be the whole answer. As we have seen, that is because the law-breaking in this
area is typically hidden, with the victims generally unaware of what has
happened. Even if it were possible – and it is certainly not desirable –
putting a policeman in every newsroom is no sort of answer.
In any
event, the powers of law enforcement are significantly limited because of the
privileges that the law provides to the press, including for the protection of
its sources. That is specifically in order that it can perform its role in the
public interest. What is needed therefore is a genuinely independent and
effective system of selfregulation of standards, with obligations to the public
interest. At the very start of the Inquiry and throughout I have encouraged the
industry to work together to find a mechanism for independent self-regulation
that would work for them and would work for the public.

No comments:
Post a Comment